Slaking Profit's Thirst
February 3, 2007
News Item: Australia's water policy is causing the country to experience a water crisis. Written by Maude Barlow.
As water becomes more rare, it is being treated as a costly commodity by governments. Late last year, I had the great privilege of giving a presentation at the International Landcare Conference on the global water crisis. What I observed as well as what I have researched about Australia's water crisis disturbed me deeply and led me to write these words of warning.
With a few exceptions, your politicians are not dealing honestly with you about the water crisis looming on your horizon. The use of the word "drought" leads people to believe that this is a cyclical situation and will end. That is not my reading. Annual rainfall is declining; salinity and desertification are spreading rapidly; rivers are being drained at an unsustainable rate; aquifers are way over-pumped - groundwater extraction skyrocketed a whopping 90 percent in the 1990s - as well as being contaminated from the 80,000 toxic dump sites under the major cities; and many surface management areas now exceed sustainable limits. Ask any farmer: Australia is running out of water.
Yet, at the very moment that massive conservation plans must be implemented and the need for public oversight of diminishing water supplies has never been greater, your governments are promoting or planning at least six ways in which your water is being wasted, exported and privatized for corporate profit.
First, obsessed with the ideology of unlimited growth, politicians refuse to question the massive export of "virtual" water from water-intensive agricultural industries such as beef (almost two-thirds of which is exported), dairy and cotton. It is simply unsustainable for the driest continent on earth to be a net exporter of virtual water - about 4000 million megalitres a year - when this water is so desperately needed at home. Not surprisingly, these water exports benefit the big agribusiness companies while bleeding water (and livelihoods) from smaller farmers growing for the domestic market.
Instead of rethinking this dangerous and short-sighted policy, your
Federal Government is negotiating a free trade agreement with China
which, by the way, has destroyed its own water resources in its drive for economic dominance.
Second, the big European water companies are running water and
wastewater systems in many of your cities, making huge profits from
your scarce water resources. Residents of Sydney and Adelaide don't
need to be reminded of the problems they have
experienced with Thames Water, Vivendi and Suez, but you need to know
that these companies have provoked a huge reaction all over the world
for their outrageous water rates, poor service and environmental
transgressions. At the fourth World Water Forum in Mexico City last
March, the United Nations documented the global failure of water
privatization and called on governments to provide water for their
citizens as a public service, not for profit.
Third, your governments are busy handing out massive bottled
water licenses to companies big and small for a pittance so they can
put your precious water in plastic bottles and sell it back to you at
exorbitant rates, all for shareholder profits. (Why would anyone choose
bottled water over Melbourne's beautiful tap water if given a choice?)
There are hundreds of domestic water brands in Australia with annual
domestic sales of around 600 million litres. Moreover, your precious
water is now also being exported in designer bottles to the rich in
other countries. A recent example is the new Coca-Cola bottling
facility outside Melbourne.
This is terrible public policy.
Fourth, your governments have set the stage for massive water
trading, brokered by private middle operators, between cash-starved
farmers and growing urban populations. The idea is to use each drop of
water in the most profitable way. (For the record, this is what China
did and is now experiencing a huge grain shortage, as its water was
diverted to industry.) Separating water from land is a recipe for
ecological disaster. The rivers and aquifers need more water, not less.
And just which farmers will be encouraged by the banks to sell water
instead of growing food? The small farmers producing for the domestic
market, that's who. Big agribusiness exporters will still get all the
water they need as long as it lasts.
Fifth, your governments are turning to big high-tech,
corporate-run "solutions" to the water crisis such as desalination,
perhaps powered by nuclear energy. Desalination plants are ugly, dirty,
intrusive, expensive, polluting and noisy. They create greenhouse gases
and release poisonous chemical brine back into the ocean. Desalination
plants are the hallmark of failure; they are what you do when you have
run out of other options. As bad as things are in Australia, you have
not run out of options.
Finally, there are plans afoot to move bulk water by tanker from
Tasmania to the thirsty cities of the coast, operated of course, by
private companies for profit. There are myriad problems, ecologically
and economically, with massive bulk water
transfers. By and large, nature put water where it is intended to be;
mass movement of water must be carefully thought through and the
decision for such a serious undertaking should never be left to those
who would stand to profit from it.
There is a historic and profound shift taking place in water policy in
Australia just at the time it is becoming clear that you have a severe
water problem. Until recently, your water was considered a common
heritage and your governments had the constitutional responsibility to
manage it in your collective name. Now, your governments have decided
that water is a commodity, like running shoes, and has set out to sell
it to those with the deepest pockets.
This is a tragedy.
International water conservation campaigner Maude Barlow was a key speaker at last year's Landcare conference in Melbourne.
Reports
- What’s Behind the Global Food Crisis? — The 2008 global food crisis is compromising the su ...















